You Get What You Comp For

A sales leader paid on win rate did exactly what he was paid to do. Then the pipeline shrank.

Tim Burnham, Founder & CEO

Tim Burnham

Founder & CEO

October 6, 2026

A sales director we heard about got paid on win rate.

So he tightened up qualification. He wrote rules about which deals were allowed into the pipeline at all.

Win rate went from about 16% to about 40%.

He hit his number. He did the job as written.

Pipeline shrank.

The simple idea

A rate is a fraction. Wins on top, deals on the bottom.

There are two ways to move it up. Win more deals, or count fewer deals.

The second way is faster. It is safer. It is completely inside one person's control, and every step of it can be defended in a meeting.

So that is the way it moves.

Nobody cheated here. Every rule he wrote was reasonable on its own. The rules just all pushed the same direction, because that is the direction he was paid to push.

How it shows up

The same shape turns up all over a sales org.

Pay on reply rate and people send fewer emails.

Pay on meeting-to-opportunity rate and fewer meetings get logged as meetings.

Pay on demo-to-close and the hard demos quietly become "not a fit."

Quality over quantity sounds like discipline. Sometimes it is discipline. Sometimes it is a smaller denominator.

You cannot tell which one you have from the rate alone. That is the whole problem with the rate alone.

What we found

The other failure is the mirror of it, and it is just as common.

One team we looked at had sent roughly 17,000 emails over ten months. Reply rate was under half a percent.

Nobody there was watching a rate. They were watching volume. The volume was real and the outcome was almost nothing.

So the answer is not "measure volume instead." Both teams made the same mistake. Each of them watched one number and let the other one drift.

A rate with no count is a story about how careful you are.

A count with no rate is a story about how busy you are.

Neither one is a story about revenue.

How to fix the comp plan

Four changes, and none of them need a new tool.

Pair every rate with a count. Win rate and wins. Reply rate and replies. If you comp on the rate, comp on the count too. It does not have to be an even split. It has to be non-zero, because a zero weight is permission.

Add a coverage number. How many accounts got worked at all this quarter. Not meetings, not opportunities. Worked. This one is hard to game downward, because the only way to move it is to touch more accounts.

Before you change a qualification rule, write down what you expect to lose. Say it out loud in advance. This rule removes about 60 deals a quarter, and I think about 4 of them would have closed. Then check in ninety days. You will be wrong sometimes, and being wrong on paper is much cheaper than being wrong in the pipeline.

Watch the rate over time, not at a point. A rate that doubles in one quarter almost never means the team got twice as good at selling. Something changed about what got counted. Go find out what.

The honest part

Tighter qualification was not the wrong idea.

Sales teams chasing deals that will never close is a real cost, and 16% is a painful place to live.

The mistake was paying for one half of the trade and not the other. He was asked to raise a fraction and he raised it, exactly as instructed.

That is what a comp plan is. It is a sentence describing the behaviour you will get.

Read yours again and ask what it would say to do if someone followed it literally. Somebody will.

Share

Working on something like this? Tell us what's slow and we'll tell you what we'd build.

Let's talk